January 22, 2005: Difference between revisions

From Gerald R. Lucas
m (Added Leighton.)
(Update after move.)
 
(2 intermediate revisions by the same user not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
{{nutshell|Hector, the champion of Ilium, chooses duty to his city above that to his family.<ref>Originally written on Jan 22, 2005 @ 1:12.</ref>}}
{{jt|title=Hector’s Choice}}


{{cquote|
<poem>
<poem>
For in my heart and soul I know this well:
For in my heart and soul I know this well:
Line 7: Line 8:
when some brazen Argive hales you off in tears,
when some brazen Argive hales you off in tears,
wrenching away your day of light and freedom!<ref>Hector to Andromache, the ''Iliad'', VI.396–397, 405–407</ref>
wrenching away your day of light and freedom!<ref>Hector to Andromache, the ''Iliad'', VI.396–397, 405–407</ref>
</poem>
</poem>}}
[[File:Andromache and Astyanax MET ep25.110.14.R.jpg|thumb|''Andromache and Astyanax'', Pierre-Paul Prud'hon, c. 1820]]
Book VI of Homer’s ''[[Homer's Iliad|Iliad]]'' shows the contention in the heart of Hector, Ilium’s champion, but also a husband and new father: he is torn between his responsibilities as a hero to his people and as a the head of the household. Like so many soldiers going off to battle today, Hector is a new father who must risk his life to maintain his people’s way of life. Hector knows that Troy is doomed, but he must do his duty as champion and prince, even though it means the enslavement of his wife and child. In Hector’s plight, we see what is perhaps the utmost position of humanity in war: to lose does not mean just the death of the hero, but his death precipitates the death of the society that he protects.


{{dc|B}}{{start|ook 6 of Homer’s ''[[Homer's Iliad|Iliad]]'' shows}} the contention in the heart of Hector, Ilium’s champion, but also a husband and new father: he is torn between his responsibilities as a hero to his people and as a the head of the household. Like so many soldiers going off to battle today, Hector is a new father who must risk his life to maintain his people’s way of life. Hector knows that Troy is doomed, but he must do his duty as champion and prince, even though it means the enslavement of his wife and child. In Hector’s plight, we see what is perhaps the utmost position of humanity in war: to lose does not mean just the death of the hero, but his death precipitates the death of the society that he protects.
[[File:Andromache and Astyanax MET ep25.110.14.R.jpg|thumb|450px|''Andromache and Astyanax'', Pierre-Paul Prud'hon, c. 1820]]
At least one characteristic of the hero in the ''Iliad'' is his resolve to meet fate bravely. Hector communicates this belief to Andromache, before returning to the battlefield:
At least one characteristic of the hero in the ''Iliad'' is his resolve to meet fate bravely. Hector communicates this belief to Andromache, before returning to the battlefield:


{{cquote|
<poem>
<poem>
::::::::::::::::Andromache,
::::::::::::::::Andromache,
Line 20: Line 22:
neither brave man nor coward, I tell you—
neither brave man nor coward, I tell you—
it’s born with us the day we are born.
it’s born with us the day we are born.
</poem>
</poem>}}


Like Oedipus’ ''anagnoresis'', Hector’s position is much the same: while we cannot avoid our fate, we can decide how we’ll meet it. Our actions are our responsibility, even though, as Achilles muses in Book IX, death will claim us all: “The same honor waits / for the coward and the brave. They both go down to Death.”<ref>IX.386–387</ref> In fact, while Hector and Achilles both seem to be considering death — under the extreme circumstances of war, what else would one think about? — they both approach it differently.
Like in Oedipus’ ''anagnoresis'', Hector’s position is much the same: while we cannot avoid our fate, we can decide how we’ll meet it. Our actions are our responsibility, even though, as Achilles muses in Book IX, death will claim us all: “The same honor waits / for the coward and the brave. They both go down to Death.”<ref>IX.386–387</ref> In fact, while Hector and Achilles both seem to be considering death — under the extreme circumstances of war, what else would one think about? — they both approach it differently.


Hector is a family man, but he is a champion first. Even though his status as the son of Priam and Hecuba is a factor, his pride affects his position, and stokes his responsibility to his people: “I would die of shame to face the men of Troy / and the Trojan women trailing their long robes / if I would shrink from battle now, a coward.”<ref>VI.389–391</ref> Hector is concerned about his place — and his perceived place — as champion; he must not let his people down. He even admonishes his brother Paris for not doing his duty, for languishing in his room instead of fighting. Yet, in this resolve — a resolve that will be put to the test in Book XXII — Hector’s responsibility will also win him glory and renown.
Hector is a family man, but he is a champion first. Even though his status as the son of Priam and Hecuba is a factor, his pride affects his position, and stokes his responsibility to his people: “I would die of shame to face the men of Troy / and the Trojan women trailing their long robes / if I would shrink from battle now, a coward.”<ref>VI.389–391</ref> Hector is concerned about his place — and his perceived place — as champion; he must not let his people down. He even admonishes his brother Paris for not doing his duty, for languishing in his room instead of fighting. Yet, in this resolve — a resolve that will be put to the test in Book XXII — Hector’s responsibility will also win him glory and renown.
[[File:Leighton-Andromache Captive.jpeg|thumb|''Captive Andromache'', Frederic Leighton, c. 1886]]
[[File:Leighton-Andromache Captive.jpeg|thumb|450px|''Captive Andromache'', Frederic Leighton, c. 1886]]
Achilles, on the other hand, questions the validity of this position. Since breaking with Agamemnon and the rest of the Achaeans, Achilles has obviously had some time to think about life. In Book IX, Agamemnon’s forces have been beaten back nearly to the ships and an embassy of heros is sent to Achilles to attempt to win him back to the battle, while Achilles sulks by his ships. After being surrounded by death, Achilles considers whether or not he should accept his responsibility as a hero. After all, he has two choices:
Achilles, on the other hand, questions the validity of this position. Since breaking with Agamemnon and the rest of the Achaeans, Achilles has obviously had some time to think about life. In Book IX, Agamemnon’s forces have been beaten back nearly to the ships and an embassy of heros is sent to Achilles to attempt to win him back to the battle, while Achilles sulks by his ships. After being surrounded by death, Achilles considers whether or not he should accept his responsibility as a hero. After all, he has two choices:
{{cquote|
<poem>
<poem>
If I hold out here and I lay siege to Troy,
If I hold out here and I lay siege to Troy,
Line 34: Line 37:
true, but the life that’s left me will be long,
true, but the life that’s left me will be long,
the stroke of death will not come on me quickly.<ref>IX.500-505</ref>
the stroke of death will not come on me quickly.<ref>IX.500-505</ref>
</poem>
</poem>}}
Achilles has decided to choose the latter course; he is determined to set sail the next morning, having lost faith in the leadership and subsequently lost faith is his hero’s pride and glory. The champion of the Greeks even advises the others to flee, since defeat seems nigh.<ref>IX.507</ref> It’s only after Patroclus’ death that Achilles is reminded of his duties to king and country, though he is motivated by that rage begun by Agamemnon and stoked to its full fury by Hector, and does his duty, establishing his fame, but cutting his life short.
Achilles has decided to choose the latter course; he is determined to set sail the next morning, having lost faith in the leadership and subsequently lost faith is his hero’s pride and glory. The champion of the Greeks even advises the others to flee, since defeat seems nigh.<ref>IX.507</ref> It’s only after Patroclus’ death that Achilles is reminded of his duties to king and country, though he is motivated by that rage begun by Agamemnon and stoked to its full fury by Hector, and does his duty, establishing his fame, but cutting his life short.


Hector does his duty for his people, but Andromache’s lament for Hector and their son in Book XXII shows how duty to country is not always compatible to duty to one’s family. Yet, the death of the family is a microcosm of the reality of the Trojans: their culture, as it is now, is doomed. Hector’s death means the inevitable defeat of Troy.
Hector does his duty for his people, but Andromache’s lament for Hector and their son in Book XXII shows how duty to country is not always compatible to duty to one’s family. Yet, the death of the family is a microcosm of the reality of the Trojans: their culture, as it is now, is doomed. Hector’s death means the inevitable defeat of Troy.


==Notes==
{{Notes|width=20em}}
{{Reflist}}


{{2111|state=expanded}}
{{Epic|state=expanded}}
{{2005|state=collapsed}}


[[Category:World Literature]]
[[Category:Greek]]
[[Category:Ancient]]
[[Category:Epic]]
[[Category:Homer]]
[[Category:Homer]]

Latest revision as of 06:42, 17 May 2023

Hector’s Choice

Book 6 of Homer’s Iliad shows the contention in the heart of Hector, Ilium’s champion, but also a husband and new father: he is torn between his responsibilities as a hero to his people and as a the head of the household. Like so many soldiers going off to battle today, Hector is a new father who must risk his life to maintain his people’s way of life. Hector knows that Troy is doomed, but he must do his duty as champion and prince, even though it means the enslavement of his wife and child. In Hector’s plight, we see what is perhaps the utmost position of humanity in war: to lose does not mean just the death of the hero, but his death precipitates the death of the society that he protects.

Andromache and Astyanax, Pierre-Paul Prud'hon, c. 1820

At least one characteristic of the hero in the Iliad is his resolve to meet fate bravely. Hector communicates this belief to Andromache, before returning to the battlefield:

Like in Oedipus’ anagnoresis, Hector’s position is much the same: while we cannot avoid our fate, we can decide how we’ll meet it. Our actions are our responsibility, even though, as Achilles muses in Book IX, death will claim us all: “The same honor waits / for the coward and the brave. They both go down to Death.”[2] In fact, while Hector and Achilles both seem to be considering death — under the extreme circumstances of war, what else would one think about? — they both approach it differently.

Hector is a family man, but he is a champion first. Even though his status as the son of Priam and Hecuba is a factor, his pride affects his position, and stokes his responsibility to his people: “I would die of shame to face the men of Troy / and the Trojan women trailing their long robes / if I would shrink from battle now, a coward.”[3] Hector is concerned about his place — and his perceived place — as champion; he must not let his people down. He even admonishes his brother Paris for not doing his duty, for languishing in his room instead of fighting. Yet, in this resolve — a resolve that will be put to the test in Book XXII — Hector’s responsibility will also win him glory and renown.

Captive Andromache, Frederic Leighton, c. 1886

Achilles, on the other hand, questions the validity of this position. Since breaking with Agamemnon and the rest of the Achaeans, Achilles has obviously had some time to think about life. In Book IX, Agamemnon’s forces have been beaten back nearly to the ships and an embassy of heros is sent to Achilles to attempt to win him back to the battle, while Achilles sulks by his ships. After being surrounded by death, Achilles considers whether or not he should accept his responsibility as a hero. After all, he has two choices:

Achilles has decided to choose the latter course; he is determined to set sail the next morning, having lost faith in the leadership and subsequently lost faith is his hero’s pride and glory. The champion of the Greeks even advises the others to flee, since defeat seems nigh.[5] It’s only after Patroclus’ death that Achilles is reminded of his duties to king and country, though he is motivated by that rage begun by Agamemnon and stoked to its full fury by Hector, and does his duty, establishing his fame, but cutting his life short.

Hector does his duty for his people, but Andromache’s lament for Hector and their son in Book XXII shows how duty to country is not always compatible to duty to one’s family. Yet, the death of the family is a microcosm of the reality of the Trojans: their culture, as it is now, is doomed. Hector’s death means the inevitable defeat of Troy.


notes

  1. ↑ Hector to Andromache, the Iliad, VI.396–397, 405–407
  2. ↑ IX.386–387
  3. ↑ VI.389–391
  4. ↑ IX.500-505
  5. ↑ IX.507
Retrieved from "https://grlucas.net/index.php?title=January_22,_2005&oldid=20146"
Powered by MediaWiki