Into the Light: More Trials for Odysseus
Book 12 of the Odyssey picks up where the journey to the Underworld in Book 11 leaves off. Odysseus and his remaining crew have successfully navigated the realm of the dead and emerge back into the world of the living, a metaphorical rebirth for Odysseus. However, their trials are far from over as they face the treacherous dangers awaiting them on the Isle of the Sun. This section of Homer’s epic tests the new-found resolve of Odysseus with trials of temptation and sacrifice.
- Odysseus demonstrates his leadership skills by returning to Circe’s island to honor and bury his fallen comrade Elpenor.
- The Sirens’ temptation highlights the power of desire and the importance of self-control and discipline.
- The encounter with Scylla and Charybdis represents the difficult choices one must make in life, often facing lesser evils to avoid greater ones.
- The disobedience of Odysseus’ crew and the subsequent destruction of their ship emphasize the consequences of disregarding divine warnings and the importance of loyalty and self-restraint.
- Odysseus’ prolonged stay with Calypso raises questions about personal desires versus fulfilling one's responsibilities and destiny.
- The book explores the themes of temptation, navigation, and the consequences of disobedience, adding depth to Odysseus' character development and the challenges he faces on his journey.
Summary
In Book 12 of Odyssey, Odysseus and his remaining crew embark on a treacherous journey after their haunting encounter with the dead in the Underworld. Their first stop is the island of Circe, where they had previously sought refuge. However, this time, their purpose is to fulfill a solemn duty.
Upon their arrival, Odysseus and his men are greeted by Circe, who recognizes them and welcomes them back. They express their sorrow over the loss of their comrade Elpenor, who had met an unfortunate end when he fell from Circe’s roof while drunk at the end of Book 10. In an act of respect and to appease the gods, Odysseus leads his crew to Circe’s house where Elpenor’s body lies. With heavy hearts, they give Elpenor a proper burial, building a mound for his remains and performing the necessary rituals. Odysseus, ever mindful of honoring the dead, also sets up an oar at the grave, a symbolic gesture to honor Elpenor’s connection to their ship and their seafaring life.
Having fulfilled their duty to their fallen comrade, Odysseus and his crew set sail once again, facing the perils of the sea. They pass the enchanting Sirens, whose bewitching voices tempt sailors to their doom. To protect his men, Odysseus has them plug their ears with wax and orders himself to be tied to the mast, enabling them to resist the lure of the Sirens’ song.
Their journey takes them to the Strait of Messina, where Scylla, a six-headed monster, dwells on one side, and Charybdis, a deadly whirlpool, lurks on the other. In this stretch of water, Odysseus must navigate the ship, making a difficult choice. He decides to sail closer to Scylla, sacrificing six men to the monster’s ravenous appetite to save the rest from the destructive forces of Charybdis.
Finally, the weary crew arrives at the island of the Sun, where they encounter the sacred cattle of the Sun God, Helios. Despite Odysseus’ warnings, hunger and desperation drive his men to kill and consume the cattle, an act of sacrilege that would bring about divine retribution. The gods, angered by the crew’s actions, unleash a furious storm upon them. Zeus strikes their ship with a thunderbolt, obliterating it and leaving Odysseus as the sole survivor, clinging to a piece of the wreckage. His resilience and resourcefulness are once again tested as he finds himself adrift at sea, navigating the waters alone.
The Burial of Elpenor
The act of honoring Elpenor holds significant symbolic and thematic importance. Odysseus’ decision to return to Circe’s island and give his fallen comrade a proper burial reflects his commitment to the values of loyalty, camaraderie, and the honoring of the dead. By taking the time and effort to perform the necessary rituals and build a mound for Elpenor’s remains, Odysseus demonstrates his respect for the deceased and the cultural traditions that dictate the proper treatment of the dead. In ancient Greek society, honoring the deceased through burial rites was considered essential to ensure their peaceful transition to the afterlife and to appease the gods.
This act also reveals Odysseus’ sense of responsibility as a leader. Despite the numerous challenges and dangers they face on their journey, Odysseus recognizes the significance of acknowledging the sacrifice made by Elpenor and the importance of maintaining a sense of unity and solidarity within the crew. It serves as a reminder of their shared experiences, hardships, and the collective responsibility they have towards one another. This act also highlights Odysseus’ role as a compassionate and just leader, who values the lives and well-being of his men—something he hasn’t always lived up to in their wanderings.
The act of honoring Elpenor resonates with the overarching themes of honor, duty, loyalty, and the interconnectedness of past and present. Odysseus' commitment to giving Elpenor a proper burial reflects his adherence to the values and traditions of his society, reinforcing the importance of upholding cultural customs even in the face of adversity. It emphasizes the enduring legacy of the past and the ways in which honoring the memory of those who came before can shape and guide the actions of the present. In this way, the act of honoring Elpenor becomes a unifying force, strengthening the resolve and determination of Odysseus and his men to continue their journey and strive for their ultimate goal of returning home.
The Sirens’ Temptation
The significance of the sirens’ temptation lies in its exploration of the power of allure, the perils of desire, and the strength of self-control. The encounter with the sirens serves as a test for Odysseus and his crew, highlighting the seductive nature of temptation and the consequences of succumbing to one’s desires.
.jpg)
The sirens, mythical creatures with enchanting voices, lure sailors to their doom by promising knowledge and pleasure. Their irresistible song captivates any who hear it, leading them to steer their ships towards the treacherous rocks where their vessels will be dashed and destroyed. Aware of the danger, Odysseus devises a plan to protect his crew from the sirens’ allure while satisfying his own curiosity. Odysseus instructs his men to plug their ears with beeswax to prevent them from hearing the sirens' song, ensuring their safety. However, driven by his insatiable curiosity and desire for knowledge, Odysseus chooses a different path. He orders his men to bind him tightly to the mast of the ship, commanding them not to release him, no matter how desperately he begs or struggles. This decision allows him to experience the sirens’ song while remaining physically restrained and unable to succumb to its enticement.
The significance of this episode lies in its exploration of the human struggle with temptation and the importance of self-control. The sirens represent the allure of worldly pleasures and the dangers that lie in indulging in them without restraint. They symbolize the various temptations that individuals encounter throughout their lives, whether it be material wealth, power, or forbidden desires. They appeal to Odysseus’ intellectual and adventurous nature, tempting him with the allure of forbidden insights and the opportunity to satisfy his yearning for understanding—knowledge of the world. The sirens’ temptation plays on Odysseus’ innate desire for discovery and challenges his self-control as he navigates the treacherous waters of their seductive song.
Odysseus’ decision to listen to the sirens’ song while bound to the mast is a testament to his inner strength and self-discipline. It showcases his ability to resist temptation and prioritize the safety and well-being of his crew over his own desires. By exposing himself to the temptation without yielding to it, Odysseus demonstrates the qualities of a true hero, one who possesses the wisdom to navigate through treacherous situations with fortitude and self-restraint.
The sirens’ temptation also serves as a reminder of the risks and consequences associated with indulging in immediate gratification. While the sirens promise knowledge and pleasure, they ultimately lead to destruction and death. This cautionary tale warns against the dangers of being swayed by superficial allurements and highlights the importance of considering long-term consequences and making wise choices.
The episode with the sirens contributes to the overall theme of Odysseus’ journey and his quest for self-discovery. It symbolizes his ability to confront and overcome temptation, grow as an individual, and maintain his focus on his ultimate goal of returning home. It showcases his resilience and unwavering determination in the face of alluring distractions and obstacles.
Scylla and Charybdis
The significance of Odysseus’ encounter with Scylla and Charybdis lies in its portrayal of the relentless and perilous nature of the hero’s journey, the need to make difficult choices, and the inevitability of sacrifice.
Scylla and Charybdis represent two formidable and deadly obstacles that Odysseus and his crew must navigate. Scylla is a terrifying six-headed monster who dwells in a cliffside cave, while Charybdis is a massive whirlpool that engulfs and spits out water three times a day. These two dangers create a treacherous passage, forcing Odysseus to choose between confronting Scylla and risking the lives of some of his men or steering closer to Charybdis and risking the destruction of the entire ship.
This encounter suggests a moral and ethical dilemma for Odysseus. It showcases the difficult choices leaders must make and the sacrifices they must endure for the greater good. Odysseus understands that he cannot avoid both Scylla and Charybdis, and he must weigh the lives of his men against the survival of the entire crew. It is a moment of immense pressure, as he must make a decision that will result in the loss of some lives, regardless of his choice.
This episode also emphasizes the concept of fate and the limits of human control. Scylla and Charybdis represent forces of nature that are beyond the hero’s power to manipulate or conquer. They remind Odysseus of the unpredictability and danger that exist in the world—that there are challenges in life that cannot be avoided or overcome entirely, and one must navigate through them with courage and wisdom.
The encounter with Scylla and Charybdis highlights the theme of sacrifice. Odysseus understands that he cannot save everyone, and he must make a difficult decision that will result in the loss of some of his men. It showcases the harsh realities of life and the sacrifices that heroes must make for the greater mission or goal. Odysseus’ leadership is tested as he must bear the burden of these difficult choices and the weight of the lives lost. Ultimately, it serves as a reminder of the courage, wisdom, and resilience required to navigate through life's perils and overcome seemingly insurmountable obstacles.
The Cattle of the Sun
Odysseus and his men reach the island of Thrinacia, where the cattle of the Sun, sacred to the god Helios, graze. Despite warnings from both the god Zeus, Tiresias, and the goddess Circe, Odysseus’ hungry and weary crew succumb to temptation and slaughter the cattle for food, going against the gods’ instructions.
The significance of this event is twofold. First, it illustrates the consequences of disregarding divine warnings and acting out of hubris. Odysseus’ men ignore the divine prohibition and give in to their own desires, believing that they can act with impunity. Their actions demonstrate a lack of respect for the gods’ authority and divine law, which ultimately leads to their own destruction.
Second, the episode with the cattle serves as a test of loyalty and self-control. Odysseus himself is torn between his loyalty to his hungry crew and his knowledge that the gods’ warnings should be heeded. He wrestles with his own internal conflict, recognizing the potential consequences of their actions. However, he is unable to prevent his men from slaughtering the cattle, as they give in to their hunger and exhaustion.
The destruction that follows is swift and devastating. The god Helios, angered by the sacrilege committed against his sacred cattle, appeals to Zeus for justice. In response, Zeus sends a violent storm that destroys Odysseus’ ship, killing his crew. This catastrophic event serves as a reminder of the gods’ power and the importance of respecting their will. It serves as a harsh lesson about the boundaries between mortals and gods, and the importance of exercising self-control and humility in the face of divine authority.
Finally, the episode with the cattle of the Sun adds to the overarching theme of Odysseus' journey as a test of his character and his ability to resist temptation. Throughout his long and arduous journey, Odysseus is repeatedly tested, and the episode with the cattle represents another moral trial for him. It highlights the importance of loyalty to the gods above men, self-control, and obedience to divine law in the face of temptation and adversity.
The Aftermath and Calypso
After the destruction of his ship, Odysseus finds himself stranded on the island of Ogygia, where Calypso resides. Calypso, a beautiful and immortal nymph, takes Odysseus in and offers him a life of eternal youth and pleasure. She becomes enamored with him and desires him as her lover, promising him immortality and endless bliss if he stays with her.
Odysseus’ time with Calypso explores longing and temptation. Odysseus, despite being separated from his homeland and Penelope, initially finds solace in Calypso’s luxurious abode and her seductive charms. He experiences a conflict between his desire for home and his attraction to the pleasures Calypso offers, not a new temptation for the hero. This episode delves into the complexities of human desires. While Calypso’s offer appears tempting, it is ultimately a distraction from his true goal: reuniting with his family and returning to his rightful place as king of Ithaca. The temptation of staying with Calypso represents a deviation from his destiny and the fulfillment of his responsibilities. Odysseus, despite his attraction to Calypso, yearns for his homeland and the comforts of his family. This longing for home becomes a driving force throughout the epic, fueling his determination to overcome the obstacles and challenges he encounters on his journey.
The episode also explores the concepts of temptation and the limits of mortal desires. Calypso symbolizes the allure of a life devoid of responsibility, eternal youth, and physical pleasure. However, Odysseus recognizes that such a life would ultimately be empty and unfulfilling. His desire for a meaningful existence, marked by the love of his family and the fulfillment of his duties, outweighs the temporary pleasures offered by Calypso.
Ultimately, Odysseus resists the temptation of immortality and chooses to pursue his journey home. His decision underscores the importance of personal growth, self-realization, and the pursuit of one’s true identity and purpose. It reinforces the idea that true fulfillment lies in the embrace of one’s responsibilities, relationships, and the connections that define our humanity.
Odysseus’ Ultimate Fortitude and Commitment
Some interpretations of Odysseus’ extended stay with Calypso (seven years!) could view it as a personal failure or a moment of weakness. Odysseus, known for his cunning and resourcefulness, might be seen as succumbing to the temptation of a comfortable and immortal life with Calypso, delaying his return to Ithaca and his responsibilities as a leader and husband.
From this perspective, Odysseus’ decision to remain on Ogygia could be seen as a departure from his heroic ideals. Instead of persevering through the challenges and dangers of his journey, he chooses a life of luxury and pleasure. This interpretation suggests that Odysseus becomes complacent and loses sight of his ultimate goal: to reunite with his family and reclaim his rightful place.
However, it is essential to consider the complexity of Odysseus’ character and the circumstances he faces. The stay with Calypso can also be viewed as a test of Odysseus’ resolve and resilience. It demonstrates his vulnerability as a human being, subject to temptation and the allure of immortality. Odysseus’ prolonged stay allows for a deeper exploration of his internal conflicts and desires, highlighting the complexities of his character and the human condition.
Odysseus’ eventual departure from Calypso’s island—after a bit of divine intervention as seen in book 1 of the Odyssey—demonstrates his growth and recommitment to his journey. It signifies a turning point in his character development, as he realizes that his true fulfillment lies not in indulgence but in fulfilling his responsibilities and achieving his destiny.
| The Epic of Gilgamesh | |
|---|---|
| The Iliad | |
| The Odyssey | |
| The Aeneid |
|
| Ovid | |
| The Divine Comedy | |
| Beowulf | |
