CompFAQ/Literary Interpretation

From Gerald R. Lucas
📝 English Composition Writing FAQ 11011102📖

On Interpreting Texts: Ways of Understanding

Literary interpretation is an essential part of analysis in the study of literature. It involves the process of understanding, analyzing, and evaluating a literary text in order to uncover its deeper meanings and themes. Literary interpretation is important because it enables readers to gain a deeper understanding of the text, as well as the author’s intentions and message. Furthermore, literary interpretation allows readers to engage with the text on a personal and emotional level, making it a rewarding experience. What follows provides an overview of the various interpretative schools and explains how literary interpretation provides a further dimension to formal analysis through various interpretive methods.

Interpretation Overview
  • Literary interpretation is the process of analyzing a text to understand its meaning and significance.
  • Interpretation involves close reading, analysis, and research to gain a deeper understanding of the text and its context.
  • Interpretation can be informed by various interpretative schools or approaches, such as reader response, feminist, Marxist, psychoanalytic, cultural, deconstructive, and post-colonial.
  • Interpretation can provide a further dimension to formal analysis, and help readers appreciate the nuances and complexities of literature.
  • To approach the interpretation of a text, students should read the text closely, identify the author's purpose, consider the context, choose an interpretative approach, analyze the text, support their interpretation with evidence, and consider alternative interpretations.
  • Research is also an important part of literary interpretation, and can help students gain different perspectives and interpretations of the text.

Literary interpretation is a subjective process that involves the reader’s interpretation of the text, based on their personal experiences, beliefs, and values, called “forestructure.” Literary interpretation is not a one-size-fits-all approach; different readers may interpret the same text in different ways, and each interpretation can be equally valid. This is because literature is a form of art that is open to multiple interpretations, and each reader brings his or her unique perspective to the text.

Literary analysis might be looked at as an objective approach to a literary text, as it examines the elements of the text itself to find meaning and insight. Literary interpretation also enables readers to engage with the text on a personal and emotional level, making insights into the text a more subjective, personal experience. In this way, literary interpretation is essential in the study of literature because it allows scholars to gain new insights into the text and to generate new ideas and theories about literature as a whole.

Interpretative Methods

There are various interpretative methods, or schools, in literary analysis, each of which offers a unique approach to interpreting a text. It is worth noting that there are no fixed boundaries between different interpretative schools, and many of them overlap or intersect with each other. For example, a feminist interpretation may also incorporate elements of psychoanalytic interpretation, and a cultural interpretation may also incorporate elements of post-colonial interpretation. Literary interpretation is an ongoing process that involves the reader’s engagement with the text, and different readers may interpret a text differently depending on their own perspectives, experiences, and values. In this sense, literature is a living art: each time we visit a text, we bring different experiences to bear on what the text means. As we grow and change, so does our interpretation of literature.

Reader Response

The reader response school of interpretation focuses on the reader’s subjective response to the text. It argues that the meaning of a text is not fixed but rather depends on the reader’s interpretation. According to this approach, the reader is an active participant in the interpretative process, and their response to the text is as important as the text itself. An example of this approach is the interpretation of Emily Dickinson’s poem “Because I Could Not Stop for Death”: a reader who has recently lost a loved one to death may interpret the poem differently from a reader who has not.

Cultural

The cultural school of interpretation focuses on the ways in which literature reflects and influences the cultural values and beliefs of a society. It argues that literature is not created in a vacuum but rather is shaped by the historical and cultural context in which it is produced. Cultural interpretation seeks to uncover the ways in which literature reflects and challenges cultural values and beliefs. An example of this approach is the interpretation of Chinua Achebe’s novel Things Fall Apart. A cultural interpretation of this novel would focus on the ways in which it challenges Western stereotypes of Africa and offers a perspective from an African cultural context.

Deconstructive

Deconstruction focuses on the ways in which literature challenges and subverts traditional ideas and beliefs, arguing that literature is not a fixed and stable entity, but rather is characterized by instability and contradiction. Deconstructive interpretation seeks to uncover the ways in which literary texts challenge and subvert traditional beliefs and ideas. An example of this approach could consider how Jeanette Winterson’s novel Written on the Body subverts the traditional narrative structure of the novel.

Ethical

Ethical interpretation focuses on the ethical and moral implications of a literary text. It argues that literature can have a significant impact on readers’ ethical values and beliefs. Ethical interpretation seeks to uncover the ways in which a text challenges or reinforces ethical and moral norms and values. For example, an ethical interpretation of Harper Lee’s novel To Kill a Mockingbird could focus on the ways in which it challenges the ethical and moral values of racism and prejudice, and promotes the values of empathy, compassion, and justice.

Feminist

The feminist school of interpretation focuses on gender and how it is represented in literature. It argues that literature often reflects and reinforces patriarchal attitudes and values, and that it is important to challenge these attitudes and values. Feminist interpretation seeks to uncover the ways in which gender roles and stereotypes are represented in literature and to offer alternative perspectives. An example of this approach is the interpretation of Charlotte Perkins Gilman’s short story “The Yellow Wallpaper.” A feminist interpretation of this story might focus on the ways in which the narrator is oppressed by her husband and society.

Formalist

Formalist criticism is a method of literary analysis that focuses on the formal elements of a text, such as its structure, language, and style. Formalists believe that these elements are integral to the meaning of a text, and that they can be analyzed independently of historical or biographical context. For example, a formalist reading of Emily Dickinson’s poem “Because I Could Not Stop for Death” could focus on the structure and language used, such as the consistent rhyme scheme and the use of imagery and metaphor to convey the speaker’s acceptance of death. The formalist approach would not consider the historical context of Dickinson’s life or the biographical details of her experience. Instead, the analysis would focus solely on the formal elements of the text and how they contribute to the poem’s meaning.

Marxist

The Marxist school of interpretation focuses on the economic and social conditions that shape literature. A Marxist critic argues that literature is not a product of individual creativity, but rather a reflection of the social and economic conditions of the time in which it was written. Marxist interpretation seeks to uncover the ways in which class, power, and oppression are represented in literature. An example of this approach is the interpretation of George Orwell’s novel Animal Farm that might focus on the ways in which the pigs represent the ruling class and the other animals represent the working class. It would analyze how the pigs use their power to oppress and exploit the other animals, and how the working class is kept in a state of subservience.

New Criticism

New Criticism is a method of literary analysis that emerged in the early 20th century and emphasizes close reading and analysis of literary texts. New Critics argue that a text’s meaning is contained within the text itself, rather than in its historical or biographical context. For example, A New Critical reading of T.S. Eliot’s poem “[[The Love Song of J. Alfred Prufrock” might focus on the formal elements of the text, such as its imagery, structure, and language, in order to reveal the underlying themes and meanings. The New Critic pays close attention to the way in which the poem’s formal elements interact with one another, and would avoid imposing external interpretations or historical contexts onto the text. Overall, New Criticism emphasizes the importance of close reading and analysis of a text’s formal elements in order to understand its meaning and significance.

New Historicist

Similar to cultural criticism, New Historicism emphasizes the relationship between literature and its historical context. This approach rejects the idea that literature exists in isolation, and instead argues that literature is shaped by the historical, social, and cultural forces of its time. New historicism also rejects the idea of a fixed, objective reality, and instead argues that reality is constructed by the various discourses and power structures of a given time period. This approach therefore emphasizes the importance of examining the ways in which language and discourse are used to construct and maintain power relations, and how these power relations are reflected in literary texts. For example, a new historicist analysis of Jane Austen’s Pride and Prejudice could examine how the language used by characters reflects the social and gender hierarchies of Regency England.

Post-colonial

Post-colonial interpretation focuses on the ways in which literature reflects and challenges the legacy of colonialism and imperialism. It argues that literature reflects the experiences of colonized people and offers a perspective from a post-colonial context. Post-colonial interpretation seeks to uncover the ways in which literature challenges and subverts traditional colonialist attitudes and values. For example, “Shooting an Elephant” by George Orwell challenges the traditional narrative of colonialism and offers a perspective from the colonized people’s point of view. The story portrays the British colonial power as oppressive and corrupt and reveals the complexities of power and oppression in a colonial context.

Psychoanalytic

The psychoanalytic school of interpretation focuses on the psychological motivations of the characters in a literary text. It argues that literature reflects the unconscious desires and fears of the author and the characters. Psychoanalytic interpretation seeks to uncover the ways in which the characters’ behaviors and actions are influenced by their unconscious desires and fears. An example of this approach is the interpretation of William Shakespeare’s play Hamlet that might argue that Hamlet’s behavior is influenced by his unconscious desires and fears, such as his Oedipal complex and his fear of death.

Steps For Interpretation

  1. Read the text closely: The first step in interpreting a text is to read it closely and carefully. Take note of the plot, characters, setting, themes, and other elements of the text that stand out to you.
  2. Identify the author’s purpose: Consider why the author wrote the text and what she was trying to accomplish. This can help you understand the author’s messages and themes.
  3. Consider the context: The context in which a text was written can provide important clues for interpretation. Consider the historical, social, and cultural context in which the text was written, as well as the author’s background and life experiences.
  4. Research the text: Find some critical secondary texts to give you some insight into to approach your analysis and interpretation. You might even use an interpretative keyword in your search to narrow the results.
  5. Choose an interpretative approach: Choose an interpretative approach that resonates with you and that you think would be effective in interpreting the text. This could be suggested by the results of your research.
  6. Interpret the text: Using your chosen interpretative approach, analyze the text in detail. Consider how the text reflects the themes and ideas of your chosen approach, and how it might challenge or reinforce them.
  7. Support your interpretation with evidence: As you interpret the text, be sure to support your ideas with evidence from the text. Use quotations and examples from the text to show how your interpretation is grounded in the text itself.
  8. Consider alternative interpretations: Finally, consider alternative interpretations of the text. This can help you refine your own interpretation and deepen your understanding of the text.
Calligraphic-swirls-flourishes-6.png

Literary interpretation is a crucial aspect of literary analysis that allows readers to delve deeper into the meaning and significance of a literary text. Through the use of various interpretative schools, readers can approach a text from different angles and perspectives, providing a richer and more nuanced understanding of the work. Each interpretative school brings its own unique insights and challenges to the interpretation of a text, enriching understanding and appreciation of literature.

The importance of literary interpretation lies in its ability to reveal the hidden depths and complexities of a text, and to show how literature can reflect and shape our cultural values and beliefs. Through interpretation, readers can engage with a text on a personal and emotional level, connecting with its themes, characters, and ideas in a meaningful way that goes beyond formal analysis. By examining a text from multiple interpretative angles, readers can gain a more comprehensive understanding of the work, and appreciate the multiple layers of meaning and significance that it contains.

In today’s complex and diverse world, literary interpretation is more important than ever. It allows readers to explore the cultural, social, and political contexts in which a work was written, and to understand how it speaks to contemporary issues and debates. By using various interpretative methods, readers can gain a deeper understanding of literature's role in shaping our worldviews and beliefs, and appreciate its enduring relevance and significance.

The importance of literary interpretation cannot be overstated. Through whichever lens one takes, interpretation enriches our understanding of literature and helps us appreciate its significance.

Written: 2002, 2022; Revised: 08-23-2023; Version: Beta 0.7 💬